2008 Christiano Ronaldo Manchester United
 2007 Didier Drogba Chelsea 20
 2006 Thierry Henry Arsenal 27
 2005 Thierry Henry Arsenal 25
 2004 Thierry Henry Arsenal 30
 2003 Ruud Van Nistelrooy Manchester United 24
 2002 Thierry Henry Arsenal 24
 2001 Hasselbaink Chelsea 23
 2000 Philips Sunderland 30
 1999 Hasselbaink Sunderland 30
 1999 Michael Owen Liverpool 30
 1999 Dwight York Manchester United 30
 1998 Sutton Blackburn Rovers 18
 1998 Michael Owen Liverpool 18
 1998 Dion Dublin Coventry City 18
 1997 Alan Shearer Newcastle 25
 1996 Alan Shearer Blackburn Rovers 31
 1995 Alan Shearer Blackburn Rovers 34
 1994 Andy Cole Newcastle 34
 1993 Teddy Sheringham Nottingham / Tottenham 22
 1992 Ian Wright Crystal Palace / Arsenal 29
 1991 Chapman Leeds United 31
 1990 Gary Lineker Tottenham Hotspur 24
 1989 Smith Arsenal 23
 1988 Aldridge Liverpool 26
 1987 Allen Tottenham Hotspur 33
 1986 Gary Lineker Everton 30
 1985 Gary Lineker Everton 24
 1985 Dixon Chelsea 24
 1984 Ian Rush Liverpool 32
 1983 Blissett Watford 27
 1982 Kevin Keegan Southampton 26
 1981 Archibald Tottenham Hotspur 20
 1981 Withe Aston Villa 20
 1980 Boyer Southampton 23
 1979 Wortington Bolton 24
 1978 Latchford Everton 30
 1977 Gray Aston Villa 25
 1977 Macdonald Arsenal 25
 1976 MacDougall Norwich City 23
 1975 Macdonald Newcastle 21
 1974 Channon Southampton 21
 1973 Robson West Ham United 28
 1972 Lee Manchester City 33
 1971 Brown West Bromwich Albion 28
 1970 Astle West Bromwich Albion 25
 1969 Jimmy Greaves Tottenham Hotspur 27
 1968 Davies Southampton 28
 1968 George Best Manchester United 28
 1967 Davies Southampton 37
 1966 Irvine Burnley 29
 1965 Jimmy Greaves Tottenham Hotspur 29
 1965 McEvoy Blackburn Rovers 29
 1964 Jimmy Greaves Tottenham Hotspur 35
 1963 Jimmy Greaves Tottenham Hotspur 37
 1962 Kevan West Bromwich Albion 33
 1962 Crawford Ipswich Town 33
 1961 Jimmy Greaves Chelsea 41
 1960 Viollet Manchester United 32
 1959 Jimmy Greaves Chelsea 33
 1958 Smith Tottenham Hotspur 36
 1957 Charles Leeds United 38
 1956 Nat Lofthouse Bolton 33
 1955 Allen West Bromwich Albion 27
 1954 Glazzard Huddersfield 29
 1953 Wayman Preston North End 24
 1952 Robledo Newcastle 33
 1951 Mortensen Blackpool 30
 1950 Davies Sunderland 25
 1949 Moir Bolton 25
 1948 Rooke Arsenal 33
 1947 Westcott Wolverhampton Wanderers 37
 1939 Latchford Everton 35
 1938 Lawton Everton 38
 1937 Steel Stoke City 33
 1936 Gurney Sunderland 31
 1936 Carter Sunderland 31
 1936 Glover Grimsby Town 31
 1935 Drake Arsenal 42
 1934 Bowers Derby County 34
 1933 Bowers Derby County 35
 1932 William Dixie Dean Everton 44
 1931 Waring Aston Villa 49
 1930 Watson West Ham United 41
 1929 Halliday Sunderland 43
 1928 William Dixie Dean Everton 60
 1927 Trotter Sheffield Wednesday 37
 1926 Harper Blackburn Rovers 43
 1925 Roberts Manchester City 31
 1924 Chadwick Everton 28
 1923 Charlie Buchan Sunderland 30
 1922 Wilson Middlesbrough 31
 1921 Smith Bolton 38
 1920 Morris West Bromwich Albion 37
 1915 Parker Everton 35
 1914 Elliott Middlesbrough 32
 1913 McLean Sheffield Wednesday 30
 1912 McLean Sheffield Wednesday 25
 1912 Holley Sunderland 25
 1912 Hampton Aston Villa 25
 1911 Shepherd Newcastle 25
 1910 Parkinson Liverpool 30
 1909 Freeman Everton 38
 1908 Westcott Nottingham / Tottenham 27
 1907 Young Everton 28
 1906 White Bolton 26
 1905 Brown Sheffield United 22
 1904 Stephen Bloomer Derby County 23
 1903 Raybould Liverpool 31
 1902 Settle Everton 18
 1901 Stephen Bloomer Derby County 23
 1900 Garraty Aston Villa 27
 1899 Stephen Bloomer Derby County 23
 1898 Wheldon Aston Villa 21
 1897 Stephen Bloomer Derby County 22
 1896 Stephen Bloomer Derby County 20
 1896 Campbell Aston Villa 20
 1895 Campbell Sunderland 22
 1894 Southwarth Everton 27
 1893 Campbell Sunderland 31
 1892 Campbell Sunderland 32
 1891 Southwarth Blackburn Rovers 26
 1890 Ross Preston North End 24
 1889 Goodall Preston North End 21